• Subscribe
  • Magazines
  • About
  • Contact
  • Advertise
Friday 27 January 2023
    IAG
    Advertisement
    • Newsfeed
    • Mag Articles
    • Video
    • Opinion
    • Tags
    • Regional
      • Africa
      • Australia
      • Cambodia
      • China
      • CNMI
      • Europe
      • Hong Kong
      • India
      • Japan
      • Laos
      • Latin America
      • Malaysia
      • Macau
      • Nepal
      • New Zealand
      • North America
      • North Korea
      • Philippines
      • Russia
      • Singapore
      • South Korea
      • Sri Lanka
      • Thailand
      • Vietnam
    • Events
    • Consulting
    • Contributors
    • SUBSCRIBE FREE
    No Result
    View All Result
    IAG
    • Newsfeed
    • Mag Articles
    • Video
    • Opinion
    • Tags
    • Regional
      • Africa
      • Australia
      • Cambodia
      • China
      • CNMI
      • Europe
      • Hong Kong
      • India
      • Japan
      • Laos
      • Latin America
      • Malaysia
      • Macau
      • Nepal
      • New Zealand
      • North America
      • North Korea
      • Philippines
      • Russia
      • Singapore
      • South Korea
      • Sri Lanka
      • Thailand
      • Vietnam
    • Events
    • Consulting
    • Contributors
    • SUBSCRIBE FREE
    No Result
    View All Result
    IAG
    No Result
    View All Result

    Royal Commission asked to find Crown unsuitable to retain Melbourne casino license

    Ben Blaschke by Ben Blaschke
    Tue 20 Jul 2021 at 13:27
    OPINION: Crown Resorts looks a natural fit for US casino giant Las Vegas Sands
    60
    SHARES
    1.5k
    VIEWS
    Print Friendly, PDF & Email

    Counsel Assisting the Royal Commission into Crown Melbourne has asked the Commissioner to find Crown unsuitable to retain its casino license on public interest grounds and breaches of Victoria’s Casino Control Act.

    Providing final submissions to the Royal Commission on Tuesday, Adrian Finanzio SC said evidence tendered during two months of hearings showed Crown should at best have its casino license suspended and at worst cancelled altogether due to systemic issues around money laundering controls, responsible gambling, tax payments and compliance.

    He also called for Crown Resorts Executive Chair Helen Coonan and Crown Melbourne CEO Xavier Walsh to be found not suitable to be associates of Crown Melbourne.

    The Victorian Royal Commission was called in February 2021 following the conclusion of a similar inquiry in NSW and the subsequent release of the Bergin Report, which recommended Crown be found unsuitable to retain its license for Crown Sydney amid revelations it had been infiltrated by criminal entities to launder money. Victoria’s Royal Commission has uncovered similar evidence alongside examples of significant tax avoidance and failure to implement appropriate problem gambling controls.

    Proposing that Crown has lost the trust and confidence of the Victorian public, Finanzio said, “The misconduct that has given rise to the loss of confidence and trust is at the most serious end of the spectrum, including systemic and repeated failings as an AML/CTF reporting entity, a provider of responsible gaming, a casino that guards against organized crime influences at the casino, a taxpayer, an employer who failed to prioritize employee safety and a regulated entity who was more concerned with the risk of getting caught than compliance.”

    These, he said, “are all matters which weigh heavily in favor of a finding that public interest be better served by not having this licensee.”

    Finanzio pulled no punches in delivering his final submissions. On the issue of responsible gambling, he stated, “There was at all times in our submission a systemic failure in Crown’s approach, placing it in continuous breach of its code.

    “These RSG (responsible service of gambling) failings have had a significant impact on the community. The evidence revealed that gambling at the casino has resulted in financial hardship, criminal activity, forced prostitution and in some cases even suicide. They together underscore, along with the legislative requirement to do this properly, the importance of the issue.

    “In addition, the evidence established a number of serious breaches of Section 68 (concerning the issuance of credit). The breaches are serious because they are obvious violations of the provisions.”

    On AML controls, he said, “Crown has failed woefully to adequately address the key risk of money laundering at the casino. At present, Crown is not at a level of readiness to combat money laundering at a level that is to be expected of the operator of a casino as sophisticated as Crown. It is, according to its own evidence, at only an early stage of maturity.

    “These are all factors which weigh heavily against suitability.”

    Finanzio did praise the efforts of Steven Blackburn, Crown’s new Chief Compliance and Financial Crimes Officer, referencing an “impressive and ambitious” financial crime reform program he has outlined for the company since stepping into the role in March.

    However, there remain concerns around how long it will take Crown to implement such changes, with Blackburn himself having set an “aspirational date of 31 December 2022 for target maturity” but with some target dates also set for 2023.

    Finanzio said he had no reason to doubt Crown’s intention to implement reform but noted serious challenges to doing so in terms of the extent of rehabilitation required, the uncertain amount of time required and the uncertainty of the outcome.

    He was also highly critical of Crown’s responses over the past two years, including throughout the Royal Commission, to adverse findings, suggesting examples of bad behaviour were still rife within the company despite the departures of several directors and senior executives since release of the Bergin Report.

    “The Casino Control Act expects of the licensee that it won’t behave like the accused in a criminal trial, standing behind the onus of proof and taking every point to avoid conviction,” Finanzio said.

    “The whole purpose of the suitability test of character, honesty and integrity is that it is expected that the onus will shift to the licensee who will behave like a fit and proper person, who will own up to misdeeds, to proactively seek to address matters of concern.

    “A licensee of good repute does not make the untenable argument but instead concedes ground. A licensee of good repute does not resist requests reasonably made or changes sought to be introduced for good reason. They appreciate the reasonableness of the request or the necessity for change, even if the request or the change causes them inconvenience.

    “The opposite has been on display over the last two years and … examples of ‘Old Crown’ behaviour has been on display in recent times,” Finanzio continued, referencing the ‘Old Crown’ phrase which Crown has recently utilized in an attempt to distance itself from its past behavior.

    “On balance it would be open to the commission to find that it is not in the public interest for Crown to retain the license.”

    RelatedPosts

    Aristocrat completes US$965 million fundraising exercise for Playtech bid

    Fitch: Strong financials has Aristocrat well positioned to pursue strategic acquisitions

    Mon 23 Jan 2023 at 08:05
    NSW industry body calls for regulatory overhaul to help clubs quash money laundering concerns

    NSW Premier looking to ban political donations from pubs and clubs as gambling reform campaign gains pace

    Fri 20 Jan 2023 at 05:33
    NSW industry body calls for regulatory overhaul to help clubs quash money laundering concerns

    NSW opposition party to slash poker machine numbers, run cashless gaming trial if elected

    Tue 17 Jan 2023 at 04:06
    Manila to drop all capacity restrictions from 1 March

    Philippines granted additional 12 months after missing deadline for removal from global AML “grey list”

    Thu 12 Jan 2023 at 05:52
    Load More

    Crown Resorts is due to present its final submissions on 3 August, with Commissioner Ray Finkelstein to hand down his final recommendations by 15 October 2021.

    Tags: Adrian Finanzioanti-money launderingAustraliaBergin ReportCrown MelbourneCrown Resortsproblem gamblingRaymond Finkelsteinroyal commission
    Share24Share4
    Ben Blaschke

    Ben Blaschke

    A former sports journalist in Sydney, Australia, Ben has been Managing Editor of Inside Asian Gaming since early 2016. He played a leading role in developing and launching IAG Breakfast Briefing in April 2017 and oversees as well as being a key contributor to all of IAG’s editorial pursuits.

    Current Issue

    Editorial: Want to attract foreigners? Make Macau the poker capital of Asia

    Editorial: Want to attract foreigners? Make Macau the poker capital of Asia

    by Ben Blaschke
    Wed 4 Jan 2023 at 11:39

    In what has become a point of widespread debate, the Macau SAR Government has called on its gaming concessionaires to...

    Singapore swing

    Singapore swing

    by Ben Blaschke
    Wed 4 Jan 2023 at 11:32

    Having previously established itself as the gold standard in the operation and regulation of integrated resorts in Asia following the...

    Flying high

    Flying high

    by Ben Blaschke
    Wed 4 Jan 2023 at 11:25

    Having endured a hectic three years at Marina Bay Sands which saw him promoted to Chief Operating Officer while dealing...

    Coming together

    Coming together

    by Newsdesk
    Wed 4 Jan 2023 at 11:21

    On 1 August 2022, Singapore officially inaugurated a new gambling regulator, the Gambling Regulatory Authority (GRA), replacing the former Casino...

    Softswiss
    Evolution Asia
    Aristocrat
    Solaire
    Solaire
    Beter
    Beter
    IGT

    Related Posts

    Manila restrictions ease as Duterte implements General Community Quarantine for National Capital Region

    Survey finds 58% of Filipinos believe POGOs damaging to the country

    by Newsdesk
    Thu 26 Jan 2023 at 18:26

    A survey exploring how Filipinos feel about their country’s controversial POGO (Philippine Offshore Gaming Operators) industry has found that a majority believe it to be harmful. Details of the Pulse Asia survey, conducted from 27 November to 1 December last...

    On the Run by Andrew W Scott, the IAG CEO Vlog

    On the Run by Andrew W Scott, the IAG CEO Vlog

    by Newsdesk
    Thu 26 Jan 2023 at 17:46

    Episode 15 of “On the Run” by Andrew W Scott, the IAG CEO Vlog. Andrew talks about his travels around the Asia Pacific region, and provides some commentary on stories published by IAG in the past week, see the links...

    Macau Chief Executive reiterates need for non-gaming investment during tour of Cotai IRs

    Macau Chief Executive reiterates need for non-gaming investment during tour of Cotai IRs

    by Pierce Chan
    Thu 26 Jan 2023 at 07:01

    Macau Chief Executive Ho Iat Seng reiterated the importance of developing more non-gaming infrastructure, citing strong hotel occupancy rates during the current Lunar New Year holiday during a visit to the city’s six concessionaires. Accompanied by the Secretary for Economy...

    Gaming credit law changes to reflect measures banning junkets from accepting player deposits

    Sands China “more than breakeven” through Chinese New Year as gaming volumes soar

    by Ben Blaschke
    Thu 26 Jan 2023 at 06:43

    Leading Macau casino operator Sands China Ltd is well and truly profitable again, the company has revealed, with gaming volumes comfortably outperforming visitation recovery during the current Chinese New Year holiday period. Speaking to industry analysts during parent company Las...


    IAG

    © 2005-2023
    Inside Asian Gaming.
    All rights reserved.

    • SUBSCRIBE FREE
    • NEWSFEED
    • MAG ARTICLES
    • VIDEO
    • OPINION
    • TAGS
    • REGIONAL
    • EVENTS
    • CONSULTING
    • CONTRIBUTORS
    • MAGAZINES
    • ABOUT
    • CONTACT
    • ADVERTISE

    No Result
    View All Result
    • Subscribe
    • Newsfeed
    • Mag Articles
    • Video
    • Opinion
    • Tags
    • Regional
    • Events
    • Contributors
    • Consulting
    • Magazines
    • Advertise
    • Contact
    • About

    © 2005-2023
    Inside Asian Gaming.
    All rights reserved.