Scientific Game

Poker pro Phil Ivey takes final shot in £7.7 million edge sorting court case

Friday, 14 July 2017 06:16
Share
Visit us

High stakes poker pro and 10-time World Series of Poker bracelet winner Phil Ivey is trying his luck one last time as he battles Genting’s Crockfords casino in the UK Supreme Court this week over £7.7 million he won playing Punto Banco in 2012.

The matter at hand is whether Ivey’s use of a technique called “edge sorting” – in which he identified tiny imperfections in the printed patterns on the back of certain cards to gain an advantage – amounted to cheating.

Ivey and playing partner Cheung Yin Sun won £7.7 million during a series of sessions in August 2012 but Crockfords refused to pay and the parties have been engaged in a legal battle ever since.

In a case closely followed by operators the world over, both the High Court in 2014 and the Court of Appeal in 2016 previously ruled in Crockfords favor, finding that Ivey’s use of edge sorting gave him an unfair advantage and therefore amounted to cheating. A nearly identical case involving US$10 million Ivey and Sun won at the Borgata in Atlantic City around the same time was also ruled in the property’s favor.

However, the ongoing saga has attracted widespread media attention not only due to Ivey’s poker fame but also because it has so strongly divided opinion on the use of advantage play on casino floors.

In this instance, Ivey and Sun requested the use of a specific type of Gemaco playing cards they had identified as flawed, then asked the dealer to rotate certain cards 180 degrees for “superstitious” reasons. As a result they were able to identify these cards in the deck and adjust their bets accordingly.

In the initial 2014 High Court case, Judge John Mitting described Ivey’s actions as giving “himself an advantage which the game precludes … this is in my view is cheating.” 

Conversely, Ivey replied, “It’s not in my nature to cheat and I would never do anything to risk my reputation.

“What we did was a legitimate strategy – we did nothing more than exploit Crockfords’ failures to take proper steps to protect themselves against a player of my ability.”

In a statement ahead of the start of proceedings on Thursday, Ivey said, "I am hopeful that the Supreme Court will reverse the decision against me and that I will finally receive my winnings which I consider to be the just and proper outcome to this dispute.”

What's new

Silver Heritage terminates consultancy agreement with Nepalese partner

Silver Heritage terminates consultancy agreement with Nepalese partner Australian-listed Silver Heritage Group Ltd has terminated its consultancy agreement with one of its Nepal-based partners after he publicly accused the company of failing to acquire necessary work permits for some senior staff at recently opened Tiger Palace Resort Bhairahawa. As reported by Inside... Monday, 26 February 2018 04:30

Inside Asian Gaming takes a look back at the biggest stories of the past week

Inside Asian Gaming takes a look back at the biggest stories of the past week Inside Asian Gaming takes a look back at the biggest stories of the past week Friday, 23 February 2018 06:55

TGG to deploy content on Solaire Resort & Casino’s gaming floor

TGG to deploy content on Solaire Resort & Casino’s gaming floor Hong Kong’s TGG Interactive has announced a deal with Manila’s Solaire Resort & Casino to integrate the Philippines casino operator to its Asian VIP and middle-class focused digital gaming machine library on the casino floor. In a press release, TGG said that the successful deployment at S... Friday, 23 February 2018 05:20

Saipan gaming commissioner accuses Macau casinos of not reporting real VIP volumes

Saipan gaming commissioner accuses Macau casinos of not reporting real VIP volumes The Executive Director of the Commonwealth Casino Commission (CCC), the gaming regulatory body of the Northern Mariana Islands, has attributed the comparatively enormous VIP rolling chip volumes running through Imperial Pacific International’s (IPI) Saipan casino to Macau operators failing to repo... Friday, 23 February 2018 05:06

Current Issue

Design For Profit

Design For Profit Architect Paul Steelman provides his insights into designing the most expensive privately funded buildings on earth and making and breaking trends. By Muhammad Cohen | Editor-at-Large EMINENT casino architect Paul Steelman helped create the Asian gaming boom with the groundbreaking design of Sands... Monday, 29 January 2018 15:11

Climbing the mountain

Climbing the mountain   ASX-listed Silver Heritage Group finally launched hotel and casino operations at its new Tiger Palace Resort Bhairahawa in late 2017, having survived the 2015 earthquake, a fuel blockade on the Nepal-India border and an AU$19 million (US$14.4 million) funding shortage as a result of the delays. ... Monday, 29 January 2018 15:07

Can sportsbooks survive a 1% tax on handle?

Can sportsbooks survive a 1% tax on handle?   The big news coming out of the United States this year is the likely striking down of the federal ban on sports betting. But with many states licking their lips in anticipation of added tax dollars, the sports betting industry may well have another crippling fight on its hands. THE US Supreme C... Monday, 29 January 2018 15:05

Herman Ng:Macau Pioneer

Herman Ng:Macau Pioneer Inside Asian Gaming discovers a bit more about Herman Ng, CEO and Executive Director of Macau-based slot machine services firm Asia Pioneer Entertainment (APE). Ben Blaschke: Can you start by telling us a bit about yourself and your background? Herman Ng: I grew up in Macau and then when I was 16 ... Monday, 29 January 2018 14:52